Past Illustrious Grand Masters
| *1860-66 | James Salisbury | *1924 | Edward M. Wheeler | *1968 | Waldemar R. Israel | 2017-2019 | Mark D. Thompson | |||
| *1866-69 | James H. Armington | *1925 | Winfield S. Solomon | *1969 | George C. Bischoff | 2019-2020 | William B. Ripley | |||
| *1869-71 | Charles R. Cutler | *1926 | Benjamin F. Downing | *1970 | Albert A. Remington III | 2020-2022 | Robert Maddix | |||
| *1871-73 | Stillman White | *1927 | Bernaed Gardiner | *1971 | George H. Ostrander | |||||
| *1873-76 | Albert A. Cushman | *1928 | Adelbert E. Place | *1972 | Saunders W. Spooner | |||||
| *1876-79 | John F. Adams | *1929 | Charles H. Holt | *1973 | William R. Smith | |||||
| *1879-81 | Amos A. Pevey | *1930 | E. Louis Morris | *1974 | George M. Lenth, Sr. | |||||
| *1881-83 | Edwin Baker | *1931 | Fred W. Johnstone | *1975 | David P. Kopech | |||||
| *1883-85 | Rev. William N. Ackle | *1932 | Herbert C. Lottsfelt | *1976 | Lawrence C. Miller | |||||
| *1885-87 | Osmond H. Briggs | *1933 | Norris G. Abbott, Jr. | *1977 | Ernest C. Bobe | |||||
| *1887 | Horace K. Blanchard | *1934 | Harry Herbert | *1978 | Kenneth P. Tillinghast | |||||
| *1888 | William J. Huntington | *1935 | Henry S. See | *1979 | Jack R. Baker | |||||
| *1889-91 | Arthur H. Armington | *1936 | George F. Ward | *1980 | John F. Damon, Sr. | |||||
| *1891-93 | Albert L. Anthony | *1937 | Harland L. Bemis | *1981 | Richard W. Armington | |||||
| *1893 | Isaac Gill | *1938 | Walter I. Cook | 1982 | Robert J. Allen | |||||
| *1894 | George W. Pettis | *1939 | George C. Clark | *1983 | Frank E. Shaug | |||||
| *1895-97 | Horace S. Richardson | *1940 | John M. Cochran | *1984 | Greene H. Gardner, Jr. | |||||
| *1897 | Enos A. Clark | *1941 | Jethro H. Peckham | *1985 | Morphis A. Jamiel | |||||
| *1898 | Charles B. Manchester | *1942 | Everett D. Higgins | *1986 | Rowland E. Hill | |||||
| *1989 | Eugene Stevens | *1943 | Alpheus S. Place | *1987 | Kenneth J. Dorney | |||||
| *1900 | William L. Chatterton | *1944 | Harrison Townsend | 1988 | Alvin R. Davis, Jr. | |||||
| *1901 | S. Penrose Williams | *1945 | Melbourne D. Brown | *1989 | Alfred Kennedy, Jr. | |||||
| *1902 | Charles A. Gillen | *1946 | I. Lee McCauley | *1990 | Curtis L. Hanks | |||||
| *1903 | George C. Knight | *1947 | William J. Kennedy | *1991 | Russell A. Grout | |||||
| *1904 | William H. Scott | *1948 | Harry A. Reed | *1992 | Earl S. Palmer | |||||
| *1905 | Fred E. Sammis | *1949 | William A. Cross | ^1993 | Stafford Sheehan | |||||
| *1906 | John F. Clark | *1950 | John D. Nelson | *1994 | Jerry I. Duhamel, Sr. | |||||
| *1907 | Robert S. Franklin | *1951 | Karl E. Falkenholm | *1995 | Nelson E. Kay | |||||
| *1908 | Charles F. Richardson | *1952 | Charles O. Davies | *1996 | Raymond A. Thomas | |||||
| *1909 | Albert Knight | *1953 | E. Elmer Johnson | 1997 | Sidney Clifford, Jr. | |||||
| *1910 | Edwin I. Mulcahey | *1954 | Alfred E. Grant | *1998 | Dewey L. Smith | |||||
| *1911 | James E. Batty | *1955 | Albert W. Claflin | *1999 | Arthur Soder, Jr. | |||||
| *1912 | Henry P. Stone | *1956 | Robert M. Brayton | *2000 | James H. Douglass | |||||
| *1913 | J. Willard Baker | *1957 | Rodolph K. Watson | 2001 | Raymond E. Hassell | |||||
| *1914 | Hugh Peden | *1958 | Raymond E. Crowell | 2002 | Robert J. Stearns | |||||
| *1915 | Norris G. Abbott, Sr. | *1959 | C. Everett MacMahon | 2003 | Douglas E. Connell | |||||
| *1916 | William H. Langley | *1960 | Carl R. Mitchell | *2004 | Hirum A. Jamiel | |||||
| *1917 | George E. Allen | *1961 | Arnold C. White | 2005 | Charles Nazarian | |||||
| *1918 | Arthur Whitehead | *1962 | David A. Home | 1999 | Marc Paul | |||||
| *1919 | Howard K. DeWolf | *1963 | Edwin O. Wilbur | 2008-9 | Steve Ringeling | |||||
| *1920 | Manton N. Coombs | *1964 | Russell E. Knight | 2010-11 | Russell T. Scanlon | |||||
| *1921 | Donald E. Spears | *1965 | John F. Hartnett | 2012-13 | Eugene Thibeault | |||||
| *1922 | Thomas P. Bassett | *1966 | C. Leigh Kingsford | 2014-15 | Charles E. Igo | |||||
| *1923 | T. Stewart Little | *1967 | John E. Johnson | 2016-17 | Mark D. Thompson |